Dana, a new associate, spent forty minutes walking a prospect through the Family Plan. The prospect loved it, then said, “This sounds great, let me think about it.” Dana said “Sure!” and never heard from her again.
If that story feels familiar, you are not alone. The “I’ll think about it” objection on a LegalShield call is the most common way a warm lead slips away, and it is rarely a real decision to wait. It is usually a polite way of saying a concern is still unanswered. Here is how to uncover that concern and keep the conversation moving without sounding pushy.
What “I’ll Think About It” Really Means on a LegalShield Call
Prospects almost never say “no” to your face. “I’ll think about it” feels kinder, so they use it. In our experience working with associates, it hides one of four things: price worry, a spouse or partner who has not weighed in, confusion about what the plan covers, or simple distrust of a stranger on the phone.
Notice that none of those are solved by time. A prospect who is confused today will still be confused tomorrow, only now the excitement has faded. That is why the objection is so costly if you accept it at face value.
Every hour that passes after a “let me think about it” cuts your odds of a callback. Treat the objection as a question you have not finished answering, not as a stopping point.
A 3-Step Response to the “I’ll Think About It” Objection
The goal is not to argue. It is to find the real concern, answer it, and agree on a clear next step. Use this sequence every time.
Step 1: Agree and Isolate
Start by validating the prospect, then ask a gentle, specific question: “Absolutely, it’s a good idea to be sure. Just so I can help, what part are you still thinking through: the cost, how the plan works, or something else?” Giving three easy options makes it simple for them to be honest.
Step 2: Answer the Real Concern
Once they name it, respond directly. If it is price, break the plan down to its daily cost and compare it to a single hour of attorney time. If it is a spouse, offer a three-way call. If it is confusion, give one concrete example, such as a lease review or a speeding ticket, that shows exactly how they would use the plan.
Step 3: Lock In a Time
If they still need time, never leave it open-ended. Say: “That’s fair. Why don’t we talk Thursday at 6, after you have had a chance to look it over?” A scheduled time turns a vague brush-off into a real appointment.
| Situation | Weak Response | Strong Response |
|---|---|---|
| Prospect says “let me think about it” | “Okay, call me when you’re ready.” | “What part are you still thinking through?” |
| Price is the hidden concern | Offer a discount right away | Reframe to daily cost vs. one attorney hour |
| Spouse has not weighed in | “Talk to them and get back to me.” | Offer a three-way call within 48 hours |
| Prospect needs time | Leave the follow-up open | Book a specific callback time before hanging up |
Follow-Up Timing After an “I’ll Think About It”
What you do in the 48 hours after the call matters as much as the call itself. Send a short text or email within an hour that recaps the one benefit they cared about most, and reference the callback time you agreed on. Then call exactly when you said you would.
If you reach voicemail, leave a brief message tied to their situation rather than a generic “just checking in.” The associates who convert these leads treat the second and third touches as part of the original conversation, not a cold restart.
Key Insight
Fresh, opt-in leads give you a real advantage here. A prospect who requested information recently still remembers why they asked, so a well-timed follow-up feels helpful instead of intrusive.
Common Mistakes When You Hear “I’ll Think About It”
- Accepting it immediately. Saying “no problem” ends the conversation before you learn the real objection.
- Over-explaining. Reciting more features rarely helps. Ask a question first, then answer only what matters.
- Dropping the price. Discounting too fast signals the plan was overpriced and weakens your credibility.
- Skipping the next-step appointment. Without a booked time, most “maybe later” leads never call back.
Practice the three steps out loud a few times. The first time you use them live, they will feel awkward. By the tenth call, they will feel like a natural conversation.
Quick Recap: Beating “I’ll Think About It”
- Agree and isolate — validate them, then ask what part they are still thinking through.
- Answer the real concern — address price, a spouse, or confusion directly.
- Book a specific time — turn “maybe later” into a scheduled callback.
- Follow up fast — send a recap within an hour and call when you said you would.
Start Every Call With a Warmer Prospect
Fresh, exclusive opt-in leads make follow-up conversations easier. Pick the package that fits your calling schedule.